What is a Ideal Weight Calculator?
Ideal body weight is a figure calculated from height and sex using one of four linear formulas — Devine, Robinson, Miller or Hamwi — all of which trace back to the Metropolitan Life insurance tables published in 1959. Each formula assumes a base weight at five feet and adds a fixed number of kilograms for every inch above it; they differ only in those two constants, which is why they disagree with each other by several kilograms at the same height.
The purpose behind them is narrower than the name suggests. Devine and Robinson were written for clinical drug dosing, where a physician needs a single number to multiply milligrams per kilogram by and consistency matters more than accuracy. Miller was fitted to a research cohort, Hamwi to diet planning. None of them surveyed healthy people to find the weight at which they thrived, and none of them asks about body composition, age, frame size or ethnicity beyond a constant offset for sex.
That does not make them useless; it makes them a dosing convention that leaked into popular use. For a general sense of a healthy weight, a BMI band from 18.5 to 24.9 is more defensible, because it was published as a range rather than a point and because it does not pretend to know anything about the individual. For anything that actually matters to health — waist circumference, body fat, blood pressure, how much you can carry up a hill — none of these formulas has anything to say.
How to read an ideal weight figure
- Enter your height and sex, and choose metric or imperial units.
- Look at all four estimates rather than the one at the top. The gap between the highest and the lowest is stated under the table and is entirely an artefact of which equation you picked.
- Add your current weight if you want to see where you sit against the mean and what BMI that corresponds to.
- Compare the formulas against the healthy BMI band. Where they overlap is the only part worth any confidence.
- Discard the number as a target. Use it as a denominator for drug dosing (its actual purpose), for estimating lean mass alongside a body fat figure, or not at all.
Ideal Weight Calculator limits and rules
| Item | Limit |
|---|---|
| Formulas | Devine (1974), Robinson (1983), Miller (1983) and Hamwi (1964) |
| Inputs used | Height and sex only — no age, no frame size, no body composition |
| Height range accepted | 120–230 cm; the formulas were fitted over roughly 150–190 cm |
| Below five feet | Flagged as extrapolation: the line simply continues downwards and the fit gets worse |
| Spread at typical adult heights | Several kilograms between the highest and lowest formula |
| Origin | Linear fits to the 1959 Metropolitan Life insurance tables |
| Published use | Drug dosing and diet planning, not a health target |
| Better alternatives | A BMI band, waist circumference, or a body fat estimate |
When to use it
- Estimating a lean body mass figure to go alongside a body fat percentage.
- Understanding where the number a clinician or app quoted you actually came from.
- Comparing a formula-based estimate against the healthy BMI band for the same height.
- Getting a rough reference weight for calculating protein or fluid needs per kilogram.
- Settling an argument about which of the four formulas is correct — none of them is, and the calculator shows the spread.
Is it private?
Your height, weight and sex stay in the page. The four formulas are evaluated in JavaScript in your browser and nothing is transmitted or stored; you can watch the network panel prove it. The only lasting copy of the result is whatever you write down.
Frequently asked questions
None of them is accurate in the sense that word implies, because they are not predictions of anything measurable. Devine is the most widely used and is what most clinical dosing guidelines reference, so it is the right choice when the number is going to be used for that purpose. Robinson and Miller are attempts to fit the same source tables differently, and Hamwi is the most generous. At a typical adult height they produce estimates spanning several kilograms, and none of them has been validated against health outcomes.
Because the formulas have no age term — they were fitted to insurance data and expressed as functions of height and sex alone. That is one of their clearest weaknesses. Population weight tends to rise modestly through middle age and fall again in later life, while muscle mass declines from around thirty onwards, so the same height can carry quite different amounts of fat at 25 and at 65. If age matters for your purpose, a BMI band used with judgement is a better tool.
No, and this is their largest failure in practice. A weightlifter and a sedentary person of identical height receive identical targets, because nothing in the mathematics asks what the weight is made of. Muscle is denser than fat, so a trained athlete can sit above every formula's estimate with low body fat and excellent health markers, while somebody within the range can carry a high fat proportion. Waist circumference handles this far better: it measures the fat that actually correlates with risk.
Not on the strength of this number. It was not derived from health outcomes, it ignores your body composition and history, and it is a single point rather than a range, which invites an all-or-nothing view of progress. If you are attempting weight loss for a health reason, the target that matters is usually set by a clinician alongside blood pressure, blood glucose and waist measurement, and it is often modest — five to ten per cent of body weight produces most of the measurable benefit.
Because each was fitted to a different dataset with a different purpose. Devine adjusted a table by eye to make drug dosing convenient. Robinson rederived the constants to fit the original 1959 tables more closely. Miller worked from a different population. Hamwi was written for dietary planning with a more generous constant. Same source data, four different lines drawn through it, and the honest presentation of that is a table rather than a single answer.
Yes, and the confusion between the two is the reason this page exists. Ideal body weight is a clinical convention with a specific technical use. A healthy weight is a range, derived from population studies of disease risk, and it depends on far more than height — waist measurement, activity, blood pressure, blood lipids and family history all carry weight. Treating the first as the second is what produces people of normal build being told they must lose ten kilograms.
Related tools
Written and maintained by Md. Nur Hossain Repon.